BFUT P29
Explaining Three Particle Generations: Why There Are Three, and Why Their Masses Obey the Koide Relation
Independent Researcher, Gurugram, National Capital Region, India
vss@vijayshankarsharma.com | ORCID 0009-0001-9622-6121
License CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 | No external funding | No conflicts of interest
Abstract
The Standard Model contains three fermion generations but does not predict their Yukawa couplings or mass hierarchy. This paper derives the structure of the charged-lepton mass spectrum from the 3 + e condensation of the Spaticle field (the name the author gives to the physical matter substrate). A mirror-symmetric arrangement of three identical cores yields one singlet and one degenerate doublet. The three cores of the 3 + e condensation of P16 co-rotate, so the arrangement is not mirror-symmetric: circulation about the threefold axis reduces the symmetry from D3h to C3h, whose irreducible representations are all one-dimensional. The most general Hermitian operator on the three cores that commutes with the threefold rotation is a complex circulant), with exact spectrum a + 2|b|cos (ϕ+2πk/3). This is identical in form to the Koide parametrisation of the charged-lepton square-root masses, so circulating threefold symmetry produces three distinct lepton levels of exactly the observed type. The three operator quantities have distinct physical roles: the on-site amplitude a sets the scale, the ratio |b|/a sets the Koide value, and the gauge-invariant loop phase Φ = 3ϕ sets the mass ratios. The Koide value satisfies Q = 1/3 + (2/3)|b|2/a2 exactly. Squaring the operator shows that each core’s mass-energy consists of a self part a2 and an exchange part |b|2 from each neighbour. The exchange entries are the discretised kinetic term and the on-site entries are the circulation self-energy, so the condensation functional of P16 fixes |b|2/a2 = A/D = 1/2, where A/R2 is the localisation term and D/R is the circulation term with D = 2A. This derives Q = 2/3 from the functional; the measured value differs by 3.30 parts per million, or 0.43 standard deviations. The P16 phase law, Φ = 2π + Q, reproduces the lepton mass ratios to 0.79 parts per million in the phase. The electron mass is the detuning ε of the link phase from its zero-amplitude value 3π/4 (the loop phase is detuned by 3ε from 2π + π/4, with me = M(1−cosε+sinε)2. The derived Koide value predicts mτ = 1776.96903 MeV, 0.43 standard deviations from the PDG 2024 average, and the complete chain from the proton mass reproduces all three charged-lepton masses to within 0.005 percent.
Keywords: fermion generations, Koide relation, mass hierarchy, threefold symmetry, circulation, C3h symmetry, condensation functional, Spaticle field, BFUT
1 Introduction
The Standard Model organises the charged leptons and quarks into three generations. It does not predict the observed Yukawa couplings, and therefore it takes the fermion masses and mixing parameters from experiment. The charged-lepton masses exhibit the empirical Koide relation
$$Q_{\ell} = \frac{m_{e} + m_{\mu} + m_{\tau}}{\left( \sqrt{m_{e}} + \sqrt{m_{\mu}} + \sqrt{m_{\tau}} \right)^{2}} \simeq \frac{2}{3}.$$
Big Flare-Up Theory (BFUT) proposes a physical Spaticle substrate and a 3 + e condensation consisting of three quark-class cores and one interstitial unit. In the resonance picture, the three observed generations are not independent ontological families. They are excitation sectors of this underlying condensation, and their masses are eigenvalues of an operator acting on the three cores.
The physical picture is the following. The three cores are bound so strongly that they cannot be separated, and all three carry the same circulation. Because each core circulates, a disturbance cannot resolve one core within a revolution. It acts on the three-core as a whole and is shared between neighbouring cores through the exchange entry b of the operator of Section 9. The resonances of the three-core are the three levels of that operator. They are collective patterns of the three cores, labelled by k = 0, 1, 2, and they are properties of the three-core itself. The direction from which the condensation is excited affects how strongly each level is excited. The levels themselves are fixed by the operator, and their ratios are the charged-lepton mass ratios evaluated in Section 9.7. The operator of Section 9 holds for every coupling that respects the threefold rotation, because the complex circulant is the most general Hermitian operator that commutes with it.
The number of levels equals the number of cores, and the number of cores is set by the condensation functional of P16. Co-rotating units bind through pairs: one unit has no pair, two units have one pair and are marginal, and three units have three pairs, a qualitative step that makes the three-core the first stable cooperative structure. At four units the arrangements 3+1, 2+2 and 4+0 have energies 1.40, 4.00 and 6.10 in model units. The minimum is 3+1, the three-core with the fourth unit outside it as the balancing unit e. The core therefore stays at three cores. Fewer than three is not stable, and a fourth core is the highest-energy arrangement of four units, so the operator acts on three cores and has three levels.
Sections 2 to 6 establish the exact geometry of the Koide relation. Sections 7 and 8 show that a mirror-symmetric operator always retains a degenerate or mirror-protected level. Section 9 derives the operator of the circulating 3 + e condensation, derives Q = 2/3 from the condensation functional, identifies the phase and the electron mass, and evaluates all three charged-lepton masses. Section 10 gives the scale relations, Section 11 the quark-sector structure, Section 12 the summary of results, and Section 13 the experimental tests.
2 Definitions and numerical inputs
For the numerical checks in this paper, the charged-lepton pole masses used are
me = 0.51099895069 MeV, mμ = 105.6583755 MeV, mτ = 1776.93 ± 0.09 MeV.
The electron value is the CODATA 2022 recommended value and the muon and tau values are the PDG 2024 averages. Their sum and Koide quantity are
Sℓ = 1883.09937445 MeV, Qℓ = 0.6666644634.
Thus Qℓ differs from 2/3 by 3.30 parts per million. The tau uncertainty alone gives σQ = 5.08 × 10−6, so the difference is 0.43 standard deviations.
Define the square-root mass vector
$$\mathbf{x} = \left( \sqrt{m_{e}},\sqrt{m_{\mu}},\sqrt{m_{\tau}} \right)^{T}$$
and the normalised democratic direction
$$\mathbf{n} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}(1,1,1)^{T}.$$
3 Mirror-symmetric threefold structure
3.1 General invariant matrix
A real symmetric 3 × 3 matrix invariant under every permutation of three identical sites must have equal diagonal entries and equal off-diagonal entries. Its most general form is
$$M_{0} = \begin{pmatrix} a & b & b \\ b & a & b \\ b & b & a \\ \end{pmatrix} = (a - b)I + bJ,$$
where J is the all-ones matrix. The democratic vector is an eigenvector with eigenvalue
λs = a + 2b.
Every vector orthogonal to n belongs to the two-dimensional irreducible subspace and has eigenvalue
λd = a − b.
The exact spectrum is therefore
spec(M0) = {λs, λd, λd}.
The full permutation group includes the mirror reflections that exchange two cores. Under this mirror-symmetric structure the three cores give one singlet and one degenerate doublet. Section 9 shows that circulation lifts the degeneracy exactly and produces three distinct levels.
3.2 Unbroken reference operator
The reference operator
$$M_{ref} = \frac{S_{\ell}}{3}\begin{pmatrix} 1 & - 1/2 & - 1/2 \\ - 1/2 & 1 & - 1/2 \\ - 1/2 & - 1/2 & 1 \\ \end{pmatrix}$$
corresponds to a = Sℓ/3 and b = − Sℓ/6, and hence
spec(Mref) = {0, Sℓ/2, Sℓ/2} = {0, 941.550, 941.550} MeV.
It is the unbroken mirror-symmetric limit of the lepton operator: one zero mode and one degenerate pair.
4 Exact geometry of the Koide relation
The angle θ between x and n obeys
$$\cos^{2}\theta = \frac{\left( \mathbf{x} \cdot \mathbf{n} \right)^{2}}{\mathbf{x} \cdot \mathbf{x}} = \frac{\left( \sqrt{m_{e}} + \sqrt{m_{\mu}} + \sqrt{m_{\tau}} \right)^{2}}{3\left( m_{e} + m_{\mu} + m_{\tau} \right)} = \frac{1}{3Q_{\ell}}.$$
Therefore
$$Q_{\ell} = \frac{2}{3}\quad \Leftrightarrow \quad\theta = 45^{\circ}.$$
With the masses above, θ = 44.9999053∘.
Write x = xsn + xd, where xd ⋅ n = 0. Then
$$Q_{\ell} = \frac{2}{3}\quad \Leftrightarrow \quad x_{s}^{2} = \parallel \mathbf{x}_{d} \parallel^{2}.$$
This is the exact representation-theoretic content of the Koide relation: the square-root mass vector carries equal squared norm in the singlet and doublet sectors. Section 9.4 derives this equality from the condensation functional.
5 Complete Koide parametrisation and the phase
Choose an angle δ in the doublet plane and define
$$\sqrt{m_{k}} = \sqrt{M}\left\lbrack 1 + \sqrt{2}\cos\left( \delta + \frac{2\pi k}{3} \right) \right\rbrack,\quad\quad k = 0,1,2.$$
The trigonometric identities
$$\sum_{k = 0}^{2}\cos\left( \delta + \frac{2\pi k}{3} \right) = 0,\quad\quad\sum_{k = 0}^{2}\cos^{2}\left( \delta + \frac{2\pi k}{3} \right) = \frac{3}{2}$$
give
$$\sum_{k}^{}\sqrt{m_{k}} = 3\sqrt{M},\quad\quad\sum_{k}^{}m_{k} = 6M,$$
and hence Q = 2/3 for the signed amplitudes at every value of δ. Physical square-root masses are nonnegative, which restricts δ to the branches |δ − 2πn/3| ≤ π/12, on which all three brackets are nonnegative. The fitted phase below lies on this branch. The relation fixes the cone on which the vector lies, and the phase δ fixes its azimuth within the doublet plane. The overall scale is M = Sℓ/6 = 313.8498957 MeV. For the ordering (e,μ,τ) a direct fit of the three measured masses gives
δ = 2.3166199 rad = 132.73254∘.
Section 9.5 identifies this phase with the loop phase of the circulating condensation.
6 Tau mass from the Koide relation
Let $a = \sqrt{m_{e}}$, $b = \sqrt{m_{\mu}}$, and $t = \sqrt{m_{\tau}}$. Imposing Q = 2/3 gives
3(me+mμ+t2) = 2(a+b+t)2.
After rearrangement,
t2 − 4(a+b)t + 3(me+mμ) − 2(a+b)2 = 0,
so
$$t = 2(a + b) \pm \sqrt{6(a + b)^{2} - 3\left( m_{e} + m_{\mu} \right)}.$$
The two roots correspond to 1776.96903 MeV and 3.31736 MeV. With the ordering mτ > mμ, the tau mass is
mτ = 1776.96903 MeV.
It differs from the PDG 2024 average of 1776.93 ± 0.09 MeV by 0.039 MeV, or 0.0022 percent, which is 0.43 standard deviations. The uncertainty on this value from the electron and muon masses is about 3.5 × 10−5 MeV for the stated electron and muon uncertainties, almost entirely from the muon mass. This is negligible beside the 0.01 MeV scale, so a tau-mass measurement with an uncertainty of order 0.01 MeV tests it directly.
7 Real single-site perturbation and the mirror-protected level
Consider the real single-site perturbation
V = diag(ε,0,0).
In the degenerate subspace, use
$$\mathbf{u} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1, - 1,0)^{T},\quad\quad\mathbf{v} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}(1,1, - 2)^{T}.$$
The projected perturbation is
$$V_{d} = \varepsilon\begin{pmatrix} 1/2 & 1/\left( 2\sqrt{3} \right) \\ 1/\left( 2\sqrt{3} \right) & 1/6 \\ \end{pmatrix},$$
with eigenvalues 0 and 2ε/3 and eigenvectors rotated by 30∘ relative to the (u,v) axes, from tan 2θ = 2V12/(V11−V22).
Adding V to the reference operator leaves $(0,1, - 1)^{T}/\sqrt{2}$ as an exact eigenvector with eigenvalue Sℓ/2 = 941.550 MeV. A real single-site perturbation preserves the mirror plane through the perturbed core, and that mirror plane protects this eigenvector. The observed levels lie far from it:
mμ − Sℓ/2 = − 835.891 MeV, mτ − Sℓ/2 = 835.380 MeV.
The observed triplet therefore requires an operator with no surviving mirror plane, which is the circulating operator of Section 9.
8 Parameter content of the lepton operator
In the symmetry-adapted basis (n,u,v), the most general real symmetric mass operator is
$$M\prime = \begin{pmatrix} \lambda_{s} + \alpha & p & q \\ p & \lambda_{d} + \beta & r \\ q & r & \lambda_{d} + \gamma \\ \end{pmatrix},$$
with six real corrections α, β, γ, p, q, and r. The Koide structure is fixed by three quantities:
- a norm law xs2 = ∥ xd∥2, which fixes Q = 2/3;
- a phase fixing δ in the doublet plane, which fixes the mass ratios;
- a scale M = Sℓ/6 in physical units.
Section 9 shows that circulating threefold symmetry reduces the six real corrections to exactly these three quantities, and derives the first of them from the condensation functional.
9 Circulating threefold symmetry and the complex circulant operator
9.1 Symmetry of the circulating 3 + e condensation
In P16 the three cores of the condensation co-rotate, so the three-core carries an axial circulation along its threefold axis.
The point group of three identical cores at the vertices of an equilateral triangle is D3h. Its elements act on an axial vector L directed along the threefold axis as follows. The rotations C3 and C32 leave L unchanged. The horizontal mirror σh, which contains the triangle, leaves L unchanged because an axial vector normal to a mirror plane is invariant under reflection in that plane. The improper rotations S3 and S35 are products of these and also leave L unchanged. The three vertical mirrors σv and the three in-plane twofold axes C2′ reverse L. The symmetry group of the circulating condensation is therefore
$$D_{3h}\mspace{6mu} \rightarrow \mspace{6mu} C_{3h} = \{ E,C_{3},C_{3}^{2},\sigma_{h},S_{3},S_{3}^{5}\}.$$
Time reversal also reverses L, so the operator acting on the three cores is complex. The two-dimensional irreducible representation E′ of D3h splits in C3h into two complex-conjugate one-dimensional representations. The doublet degeneracy of Section 3 is protected only by the vertical mirrors and time reversal, and circulation removes both.
9.2 The most general C3-invariant Hermitian operator and its exact spectrum
Let C be the cyclic shift of the three cores, C3 = I. The most general Hermitian 3 × 3 operator commuting with C is the complex circulant
$$X = aI + bC + b^{*}C^{2} = \begin{pmatrix} a & b & b^{*} \\ b^{*} & a & b \\ b & b^{*} & a \\ \end{pmatrix},\quad\quad a \in \mathbb{R},\quad b = |b|e^{i\phi}.$$
The eigenvectors are the discrete Fourier modes $\mathbf{f}_{k} = \left( 1,\omega^{k},\omega^{2k} \right)^{T}/\sqrt{3}$ with ω = e2πi/3, and Cfk = ωkfk. The exact eigenvalues are
$$x_{k} = a + b\,\omega^{k} + b^{*}\omega^{- k} = a + 2|b|\cos\left( \phi + \frac{2\pi k}{3} \right),\quad\quad k = 0,1,2.$$
Two eigenvalues coincide only when ϕ is an integer multiple of π/3, which includes the real case of Section 3. For every other value of ϕ the three eigenvalues are distinct. Circulating threefold symmetry therefore produces three distinct levels directly.
The spectrum depends on ϕ only through the loop phase
Φ = 3ϕ,
because shifting ϕ by 2π/3 only relabels k. The loop phase is the phase accumulated by an amplitude that passes once around the three cores, and it is the gauge-invariant phase of the operator: a rephasing of the individual core amplitudes redistributes the phase among the three links and leaves their sum unchanged.
9.3 Identification with the Koide parametrisation
The spectrum of Section 9.2 has exactly the form of the Koide parametrisation of Section 5. The identification
$$a = \sqrt{M},\quad\quad|b| = \sqrt{M/2},\quad\quad\phi = \delta$$
maps the eigenvalues xk onto the square-root masses $\sqrt{m_{k}}$. The mass operator is Mℓ = X2, a C3-invariant Hermitian circulant with eigenvalues mk = xk2. The masses are quadratic in the eigenvalues of the circulating amplitude operator, in the same way that the energy of a linear oscillation is quadratic in its amplitude.
The six real corrections of Section 8 reduce to three real quantities, each with a distinct physical role:
- the on-site amplitude a, which fixes the absolute scale M = a2;
- the exchange-to-on-site ratio |b|/a, which fixes the Koide value;
- the loop phase Φ = 3ϕ, which fixes the mass ratios.
A complex circulant with a phase near 2/9 was noted empirically for the charged leptons by Brannen (2010), without a physical origin. In BFUT the operator is the most general one allowed by the circulating 3 + e condensation, and Section 9.4 fixes its norm ratio from the condensation functional.
9.4 Derivation of the norm law from the condensation functional
Split X into its on-site part DX = aI and its exchange part H = bC + b*C2. From Section 9.2, $\sum_{k}^{}x_{k} = 3a$ and $\sum_{k}^{}x_{k}^{2} = 3a^{2} + 6|b|^{2}$, so
$$Q = \frac{\sum_{k}^{}x_{k}^{2}}{\left( \sum_{k}^{}x_{k} \right)^{2}} = \frac{1}{3} + \frac{2}{3}\,\frac{|b|^{2}}{a^{2}}.$$
The first term is the singlet share, fixed by threefold symmetry. The second term is set by one ratio, |b|2/a2.
The meaning of that ratio follows from the mass operator Mℓ = X2. Its diagonal element, the mass-energy carried by each core, is
(X2)jj = a2 + 2|b|2.
Each core therefore carries a self part a2 and an exchange part |b|2 from each of its two neighbours. The cross terms between on-site and exchange parts vanish in the trace because Tr C = Tr C2 = 0.
The condensation functional of P16,
$$E(R) = \frac{A}{R^{2}} + BR^{2} + CR + \frac{D}{R},$$
contains exactly one term of each of these two kinds. The localisation term A/R2 is the quantum kinetic cost of confining substrate amplitude, A = ℏ2/(2meff). The circulation term D/R is the energy of one complete phase winding, D = ℏc. The bulk term BR2 and the boundary term CR fix the envelope radius R0 and do not act between cores.
In a three-core operator, the exchange entries are the kinetic term: transfer of amplitude from one core to its neighbour is the discretised form of the kinetic operator, exactly as a hopping amplitude is the discretised kinetic energy on any lattice. The on-site entries are the self-energy of each core, and in BFUT each core is a co-rotating condensation whose self-energy is its circulation. The two quanta are therefore
$$|b|^{2} \leftrightarrow \varepsilon_{A} = \frac{p^{2}}{2m_{eff}},\quad\quad a^{2} \leftrightarrow \varepsilon_{D} = pc,$$
both for the same circulating amplitude of momentum p. P16 fixes the effective mass by meff = ℏ/(c ℓmodel), so the circulating amplitude carries p = ℏ/ℓmodel = meffc. Then
$$\frac{|b|^{2}}{a^{2}} = \frac{\varepsilon_{A}}{\varepsilon_{D}} = \frac{p}{2m_{eff}c} = \frac{1}{2},$$
which is the model-unit identity D = 2A of P16, with A = 1/2 and D = 1. The ratio is independent of R0, of ρs, and of every measured constant. Therefore
$$Q = \frac{1}{3} + \frac{2}{3} \cdot \frac{A}{D} = \frac{1}{3} + \frac{1}{3} = \frac{2}{3}.$$
The Koide value is the singlet share 1/3 plus the exchange share (2/3)(1/2), and the factor 1/2 is the kinetic factor of the localisation term measured against one circulation quantum. Equivalently, the self and exchange parts of each core’s mass-energy are equal, a2 = 2|b|2, and the on-site and exchange parts of X carry equal Frobenius weight, 3a2 = 6|b|2. This is the operator form of the singlet-doublet norm equality of Section 4.
The assignment is unique. Exchanging the roles of the two terms gives |b|2/a2 = D/A = 2 and Q = 5/3, outside the range 1/3 ≤ Q ≤ 1 of any triplet of non-negative square-root masses. Only the kinetic-exchange, circulation-on-site assignment describes a physical mass triplet.
The derived value compares with the measured Qℓ = 0.6666644634 at a difference of 3.30 parts per million, or 0.43 standard deviations. With Q = 2/3 derived, the tau mass of Section 6, 1776.96903 MeV, is a BFUT prediction from the electron and muon masses.
The factor 1/2 is the ratio of the two coefficients of the condensation functional, evaluated at the circulating momentum p = meff c fixed by P16. The localisation term has coefficient A = ħ2/(2meff) and the circulation term has coefficient D = ħc. With meff c = ħ/ℓmodel, the two terms at R = ℓmodel are ħc/(2ℓmodel) and ħc/ℓmodel, and their ratio is 1/2. The value of the factor implied by the measured masses is (3Qℓ − 1)/2 = 0.4999967, which differs from 1/2 by −6.6 parts per million with an uncertainty of 15.2 parts per million. The 3.30 parts per million difference of Q therefore lies within the experimental uncertainty of the tau mass.
9.5 The loop phase and the P16 phase law
P16 defines the charged-lepton phase by
$$\delta = \frac{2\pi + Q}{3}.$$
In the circulating operator this law has a direct reading. Since ϕ = δ, the loop phase is
Φ = 3δ = 2π + Q.
The amplitude that circles the three cores accumulates one complete winding plus an excess phase equal to Q radians. With Q = 2/3 the law gives δ = 2π/3 + 2/9, that is, an excess phase per link of δ0 = 2/9 rad.
With Q = 2/3, the phase that reproduces the measured ratio mμ/me = 206.7682827 is
δ0 = 0.2222220471 rad,
and the corresponding excess loop phase is 3δ0 = 0.6666661412 rad. The P16 value 2/3 agrees with this to 0.79 parts per million.
9.6 The electron as a link-phase detuning
The square-root electron amplitude vanishes exactly when $1 + \sqrt{2}\cos\delta = 0$, that is, at δ = 3π/4, or loop phase Φ0 = 2π + π/4. Write the actual phase as δ = 3π/4 − ε. Then exactly
$$\sqrt{2}\cos\left( \frac{3\pi}{4} - \varepsilon \right) = \sin\varepsilon - \cos\varepsilon,$$
and
me = M(1−cosε+sinε)2 = Mε2(1+ε+O(ε2)).
The measured masses give ε = π/12 − δ0 = 0.0395773 rad, or 2.26761∘. The electron is light because the loop phase of the circulating condensation lies close to the value at which the lightest mode has zero amplitude, and its mass is quadratic in the detuning. The lift of the electron from the zero mode of Section 3.2 is the phase detuning itself.
Under the P16 phase law the detuning of the loop phase is
$$3\varepsilon = \frac{\pi}{4} - \frac{2}{3} = 0.1187315\ rad,$$
and the law gives me/M = 0.00162812, against the observed value 0.00162813, a difference of 0.0009 percent. The electron mass is nonzero because 2/3 differs from π/4.
9.7 Complete three-mass evaluation
With the derived norm law Q = 2/3 and the P16 phase law δ = 2π/3 + 2/9, all three charged-lepton masses follow from one scale. Three scale inputs are evaluated below: the lepton sum, the W-boson relation of Section 10.1 with the PDG 2024 W mass, and the BFUT electron relation me = mp/(6π5) of P16, which sets the scale through the electron. The same numerical ratio mp/me ≃ 6π5 was noted empirically by Lenz (1951), without a mechanism.
| Scale input | me (MeV) | mμ (MeV) | mτ (MeV) |
|---|---|---|---|
| M = Sℓ/6 | 0.510984 (Difference −0.0030%) | 105.6563 (Difference −0.0020%) | 1776.932 (Difference +0.0001%) |
| M = mW/256 | 0.511134 (Difference +0.0264%) | 105.6873 (Difference +0.0274%) | 1777.455 (Difference +0.0295%) |
| me = mp/(6π5) | 0.5110086 (Difference +0.0019%) | 105.6614 (Difference +0.0029%) | 1777.018 (Difference +0.0050%) |
| Measured | 0.51099895069 | 105.6583755 | 1776.93 ± 0.09 |
The third row reproduces all three charged-lepton masses from the proton mass to within 0.005 percent, with the tau value 0.98 standard deviations from the measurement. The second row lies 1.7 standard deviations from the measured tau mass once the W-mass uncertainty of ±13.3 MeV is propagated.
10 Scale relations
10.1 W-boson relation
P29 proposes a relation between the charged-lepton Koide scale and the W-boson mass. P19 evaluates the same W relation with the proton-based scale M = mp/3, as set out below. Written in mass units,
$$\frac{S_{\ell}}{6} = \frac{m_{W}}{256},\quad\quad\text{or}\quad\quad S_{\ell} = \frac{3m_{W}}{128},$$
where P19 derives the factor 256 = 44 from the sixteen coherent reconfiguration amplitudes of the n = 4 four-unit condensation of P16, with mass quadratic in amplitude. Using the PDG 2024 world average mW = 80369.2 ± 13.3 MeV gives Sℓ = 1883.653 ± 0.312 MeV, which differs from the observed sum by 0.554 MeV, or 0.0294 percent, which is 1.8 standard deviations.
P19 evaluates the charged resonance from the proton mass alone as mW_vss = 256M = (256/3)mp = 80.066 GeV, with M = mp/3 = 312.757 MeV. Within the operator of Section 9, with the scale fixed through the electron, me = mp/(6π⁵), the on-site scale a² = Sℓ/6 = 313.865 MeV gives 256a² = 80.349 GeV, 0.025 percent below the PDG 2024 average. The P29 scale 313.865 MeV is 0.35 percent above the P19 scale 312.757 MeV, and the corresponding W values differ by 0.283 GeV.
10.2 Confinement scale
With the P16 values Fconf = 0.574 GeV/fm and rq = 0.3905 fm, Fconfrq = 224.147 MeV and the on-site scale of the circulating operator satisfies
$$\frac{a^{2}}{F_{conf}r_{q}} = \frac{S_{\ell}/6}{F_{conf}r_{q}} = 1.40020,$$
which lies 0.34 percent from $\pi/\sqrt{5} = 1.40496$.
10.3 Proton scale
Using the CODATA 2022 value mp = 938.27208943 MeV gives
Sℓ − 2mp = 6.55520 MeV,
or equivalently
$$M = \frac{S_{\ell}}{6} = \frac{m_{p}}{3} + 1.0925\ MeV.$$
The Koide scale equals the mass per core of the three-core to 0.349 percent. In the 3 + e picture the on-site amplitude of the lepton operator and the mass per core of the proton are set by the same condensation.
11 Quark sector
A real symmetric circulant 3 × 3 matrix retains a degenerate pair, and the complex circulant of Section 9 removes that degeneracy for the quark sectors as well, since three-core circulation is common to all sectors of the condensation. Each quark sector is described by its own on-site/exchange ratio and its own loop phase. Two circulants built on the same shift operator C share the Fourier eigenvectors fk, so quark mixing arises from the sector-dependent departure of the up-type and down-type operators from pure circulant form. The CKM matrix is the relative rotation between the two sets of eigenvectors.
12 Summary of results
| Result | Content | Numerical outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Three distinct levels | Circulation reduces D3h to C3h; the most general operator is a complex circulant with three distinct eigenvalues of exact Koide form. | Exact |
| Koide value Q = 2/3 | Q = 1/3 + (2/3)|b|2/a2 with |b|2/a2 = A/D = 1/2 from the localisation and circulation terms of the condensation functional. | Difference 3.30 ppm, 0.43σ |
| Loop phase | The mass ratios are set by the gauge-invariant loop phase Φ = 3ϕ; the P16 law Φ = 2π + Q. | Difference 0.79 ppm in phase |
| Electron mass | Link-phase detuning ε from 3π/4; the loop phase is detuned by 3ε from 2π + π/4; me = M(1−cosε+sinε)2. | Difference 0.0009% in me/M |
| Tau mass | mτ = 1776.96903 MeV from the derived Koide value. | Difference 0.0022%, 0.43σ |
| Proton chain | All three charged-lepton masses from mp. | Within 0.005% |
| W-boson relation | Sℓ = 3mW/128. | Difference 0.0294%, 1.8σ |
| Proton scale | M = mp/3 + 1.0925 MeV. | Difference 0.349% |
| Confinement scale | (Sℓ/6)/(Fconfrq) = 1.40020 against $\pi/\sqrt{5}$. | Difference 0.34% |
13 Experimental tests
The results of this paper supply direct tests.
- The derived Koide value fixes mτ = 1776.96903 MeV with negligible input uncertainty. A tau-mass measurement at the 0.01 MeV level tests the norm law directly.
- With Q = 2/3, the P16 phase law fixes mμ/me at 206.770316, against the measured 206.7682827.
- The circulating operator applies to each fermion sector, so the up-type and down-type quark spectra and the CKM matrix follow from the same structure in a declared renormalisation convention.
14 Conclusion
Mirror-symmetric threefold structure yields a singlet plus a degenerate doublet. The three cores of the 3 + e condensation of BFUT co-rotate, so the condensation is not mirror-symmetric. Circulation reduces D3h to C3h, removes the protection of the doublet, and makes the most general operator on the three cores a complex circulant whose exact spectrum has the Koide form. Threefold circulation therefore explains why there are three distinct charged-lepton levels and why their square roots take the one-phase form observed in nature.
Within this operator the charged-lepton spectrum is fixed by three quantities. The Koide value is derived: the condensation functional fixes the exchange-to-self ratio at A/D = 1/2, and Q = 1/3 + (2/3)(1/2) = 2/3, within 3.30 parts per million of measurement. The mass ratios are set by the gauge-invariant loop phase, for which the P16 law Φ = 2π + Q agrees to 0.79 parts per million. The electron is the small detuning ε of the link phase from its zero-amplitude value (3ε in the loop phase), and its mass is quadratic in ε. The scale is the on-site amplitude, tied to the W-boson mass at 0.029 percent and to the proton mass at 0.002 to 0.005 percent through the electron. The derived tau mass, 1776.96903 MeV, provides the most direct experimental test.
References
Brannen, C. A. (2010). Spin path integrals and generations. Foundations of Physics, 40, 1681-1699. arXiv:1006.3114
Koide, Y. (1983). A fermion-boson composite model of quarks and leptons. Physics Letters B, 120, 161-165. https://doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(83)90635-0
Lenz, F. (1951). The ratio of proton and electron masses. Physical Review, 82, 554.
Mohr, P. J., Newell, D. B., Taylor, B. N., and Tiesinga, E. (2024). CODATA recommended values of the fundamental physical constants: 2022. arXiv:2409.03787
Particle Data Group. (2024). Review of Particle Physics. Physical Review D, 110, 030001. https://pdg.lbl.gov
Sharma, V. S. (2026). The Origin of Matter, Antimatter, and Fundamental Forces: How Protons, Electrons, and Hydrogen Formed. BFUT P16. Zenodo. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19908215
Sharma, V. S. (2026). The Emergence of Forces and Fundamental Senses: How the Spaticle Field Gave Rise to Gravity and All Other Forces. BFUT P17. Zenodo. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19976408
Sharma, V. S. (2026). Beyond General Relativity: A Unified Gravitation Equation Across Quantum, Classical, Galactic, and Rapid-Transition Regimes. BFUT P18. Zenodo. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.20145506
Sharma, V. S. (2026). Unification of Particle Physics: Deriving Fine Structure and Coupling Constants, W, Z, and Higgs Boson Masses, Redefining and Unifying Gravity and Time. BFUT P19. Zenodo. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.20145567